Name: Sunset Beach Shelter Island
Address: Shelter Island, United States
Price range: 475 GBP
Rating: 7.8

1-24 out of 24

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

Sunset Beach Shelter Island

Hotel

7.8

Very good26 reviews

Map

2.3 km from City Centre

While staying at the Sunset Beach you are invited to discover Greenport, set around 3.8 km away, or Shelter Island, which is around 2.6 km away.

From£ 475 /nightSelect

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island

Hotel

8.6

Great43 reviews

Map

3.1 km from City Centre

Located 10 minutes by car from Shelter Island in Shelter Island, the Pridwin offers a wellness centre and a spa lounge including a steam room, a sauna and an outdoor swimming pool.

From£ 266 /nightSelect

Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island

Bed & Breakfast

8.6

Great8 reviews

Map

1.9 km from City Centre

You can relax by an outdoor pool in the traditional Seven - A Boutique B&B On, located within 10 minutes' walk of Shelter Island Country Club.

From£ 656 /nightSelect

Rams Head Inn

Hotel

8.2

Great9 reviews

Map

3.8 km from City Centre

Fireboat Firefighter Museum is 15 minutes by car from the Ram'S Head and Shelter Island is about 3.8 km away.

From£ 358 /nightSelect

Places to stay near Shelter Island

Shelter Island House

Hotel

8.6

Great20 reviews

Map

1.9 km from Shelter Island1.9 km from City Centre

Set 3.8 km from Nova Constellatio Gallery, the smoke-free Shelter Island House offers 11 rooms and a seasonal outdoor swimming pool.

From£ 160 /nightSelect

The Blue Inn At North Fork

Inn

7.4

Very good9 reviews

Map

6.2 km from Shelter Island6.2 km from City Centre

The 3-star Blue Inn At North Fork is a good starting point to East Marion's sights including Lavender By the Bay Farm, which is 5 minutes' walk away.

From£ 148 /nightSelect

Baron'S Cove

Hotel

8.4

Great59 reviews

Map

8.2 km from Shelter Island8.2 km from City Centre

The 4-star Baron'S Cove is located in the charming part of Sag Harbor, within 10 minutes' drive of Foster Memorial Town Beach.

From£ 175 /nightSelect

Sound View Greenport

Hotel

8.4

Great62 reviews

Map

5.7 km from Shelter Island5.7 km from City Centre

Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum is located about a 10-minute ride from the 3-star Sound View, while you can enjoy sauna facilities and an outdoor swimming pool on-site.

From£ 254 /nightSelect

The Harbor Front Inn

Hotel

8.4

Great51 reviews

Map

4.2 km from Shelter Island4.2 km from City Centre

Located just a 5-minute walk from East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation, the 3-star Harbor Front Inn Greenport is 2.9 km from Lavender By the Bay Farm.

From£ 241 /nightSelect

American Beech Hotel

Hotel

8.4

Great54 reviews

Map

4.4 km from Shelter Island4.4 km from City Centre

Lavender By the Bay Farm and Railroad Museum of Long Island are respectively 2.5 km and 700 metres from the smoke-free American Beech.

From£ 183 /nightSelect

The Menhaden Hotel

Hotel

8.0

Great23 reviews

Map

4.2 km from Shelter Island4.2 km from City Centre

Set less than 5 minutes on foot from Greenport, the 4-star Menhaden can arrange windsurfing, hiking and mini golf a 5-minute ride from Dering Harbor Marina.

From£ 307 /nightSelect

A Walk In The Woods Bed And Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast

8.4

Great29 reviews

Map

5.9 km from Shelter Island5.9 km from City Centre

Founders Landing Park is within a 10-minute drive of the 3-star Walk In The Woods and Southold Bay Oysters is a 19-minute stroll away.

From£ 275 /nightSelect

Greenporter Hotel

Hotel

8.4

Great40 reviews

Map

4.3 km from Shelter Island4.3 km from City Centre

Set around a 5-minute walk from East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation and in the historic district of Greenport, the 3-star Greenporter has 34 rooms.

From£ 136 /nightSelect

The Chequit

Inn

8.6

Great28 reviews

Map

2.2 km from Shelter Island2.2 km from City Centre

Placed 5 minutes on foot from Crescent Beach, the 4-star Chequit welcomes guests with a restaurant and a shop.

From£ 735 /nightSelect

House On Chase Creek

Bed & Breakfast

8.4

Great16 reviews

Map

1.9 km from Shelter Island1.9 km from City Centre

Fireboat Firefighter Museum is 10 minutes by car from the 4-star House On Chase Creek Bed & Breakfast and Lavender By the Bay is a 10-minute ride away.

From£ 246 /nightSelect

Harbor Knoll Bed And Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast

8.6

Great16 reviews

Map

4.0 km from Shelter Island4.0 km from City Centre

The 3-star Harbor Knoll Bed And Breakfast with sea views lies 9 minutes' stroll from Greenport Antique Carousel.

From£ 263 /nightSelect

The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport

Bed & Breakfast

8.6

Great32 reviews

Map

4.4 km from Shelter Island4.4 km from City Centre

Greenport is also set only 12 minutes' walk from the 4-star Stirling House Waterfront Inn.

From£ 535 /nightSelect

Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast

8.6

Great34 reviews

Map

6.5 km from Shelter Island6.5 km from City Centre

Approximately 85 km from Long Island MacArthur airport, the 5-star Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast East Marion offers a spa salon for guests' enjoyment.

From£ 228 /nightSelect

Fordham House

Hotel

Map

5.1 km from Shelter Island5.1 km from City Centre

Featuring free self parking and a picnic area, this property is situated a short distance from Nova Constellatio Gallery.

Select

Southold Beach Motel

Motel

8.6

Great4 reviews

Map

6.7 km from Shelter Island6.7 km from City Centre

Set 4 km from Railroad Museum of Long Island, the 2-star Beach Motel Southold features 14 rooms with private bathrooms.

From£ 179 /nightSelect

Zey Hotel

Bed & Breakfast

8.0

Great13 reviews

Map

4.4 km from Shelter Island4.4 km from City Centre

While staying at the Zey you are invited to discover Kontokosta Winery, set around 5 minutes away by car, or Lavender By the Bay, which is 10 minutes away by car.

From£ 820 /nightSelect

Hotel Moraine

Hotel

9.4

Perfect2 reviews

Map

5.6 km from Shelter Island5.6 km from City Centre

Featuring 13 rooms with views of the sea, the Moraine Greenport is set 2.8 km from Kontokosta Winery.

From£ 493 /nightSelect

Sag Harbor Inn

Hotel

8.2

Great10 reviews

Map

8.1 km from Shelter Island8.1 km from City Centre

Featuring an outdoor swimming pool and 42 rooms, the 3-star Sag Harbors is just a 10-minute walk from Christ Episcopal Church.

Select

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Hotel

Map

4.3 km from Shelter Island4.3 km from City Centre

Dering Harbor Marina is set within 2.7 km of the Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows Greenport.

From£ 419 /nightSelect

FAQs about hotels in Shelter Island

We hope that the answers to these questions will help you plan your trip

What are the top properties for couples in Shelter Island?

According to HotelMix.co.uk travel data, there are 3 deals for couples. The Pridwin Hotel rated 8.6/10 is a favourite 4-star hotel for couples, featuring an outdoor swimming pool, a golf course, and a spa lounge. Guests can book a room at this property for about 264£ per night. To see more romantic hotels click here.

What are the top places to stay in Shelter Island with outdoor pools?

You may also like Seven - A Boutique B&B On rated 9.6/10. This property will cost you 650£ per night.

Which hotels are the top ones to stay at in Shelter Island?

You may like Seven - A Boutique B&B On rated 9.6/10 featuring an outdoor swimming pool, a picnic area, and a golf course. It costs 650£ per night. Also, you may book The Pridwin Hotel (rating: 8.6/10), a fantastic hotel with an outdoor swimming pool, a golf course, and a spa lounge. It costs about 264£ per night.

Which spa hotels in Shelter Island are the best?

You may book The Pridwin Hotel, a nice spa hotel featuring an outdoor swimming pool, a golf course, and a steam room. It costs 264£ per night. As an alternative, book Rams Head Inn (rating: 8.2/10), which costs 173£ per night and offers a picnic area, yoga classes, and children's menu.

How much is it to stay a night in Shelter Island?

According to HotelMix.co.uk travel data, the average prices for Shelter Island hotels are:
A 4-star hotel room costs 264£ per night. You may book The Pridwin Hotel with an outdoor swimming pool, a golf course, and a steam room.

How much does it cost to stay in a Shelter Island hotel for tonight?

According to HotelMix.co.uk travel data, the average Shelter Island prices for tonight are:
Seven - A Boutique B&B On (rating: 9.6/10) may cost you about 173£ per night.

What are the best beach hotels in Shelter Island?

To make your stay fantastic, there are 3 options to consider. Alternatively, book Rams Head Inn rated 8.2/10, a nice property set 400 metres from the beach. It costs 173£ per night and provides a picnic area, yoga classes, and children's menu.