Fishers Island NY Hotels

Search among 48 available hotels and places to stay in Fishers Island from 50+ providers

Check-in
Sat, 15 Jun
-
Check-out
Sun, 16 Jun
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Check-in
Sat, 15 Jun
-
Check-out
Sun, 16 Jun
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
Check-in
Sat, 15 Jun
-
Check-out
Sun, 16 Jun
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
View map
1-48 out of 48
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
Crystal Cove By Cozykey Vacation Rentals Fishers Island
Hotel
Map
1680.0 km from City Centre
Featuring an outdoor swimming pool, this luxury venue gives access to Island Grove Wine Company at Formosa Gardens.
Select
Places to stay near Fishers Island
8.4
Great162 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
The Hilton is situated near the historical district of Mystic, within 5 minutes' stroll of Cornerstone Playhouse and offers fitness classes and entertainment activities.
From£ 93 /nightSelect
8.4
Great46 reviews
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
Guests can have a buffet breakfast and enjoy visiting Mystic Seaport Museum, set around 25 minutes' walk from the Residence Inn Mystic Groton.
From£ 209 /nightSelect
8.4
Great127 reviews
Map
9.0 km from Fishers Island9.0 km from City Centre
The 3-star Inn At has a coffee bar and a swimming pool on site and is situated near a train station.
From£ 61 /nightSelect
8.4
Great588 reviews
Map
12.1 km from Fishers Island12.1 km from City Centre
Located about 70 km from T.F. Green airport, the Spark By Hilton Mystic Groton Mystic features a continental breakfast.
From£ 50 /nightSelect
8.2
Great29 reviews
Map
15.9 km from Fishers Island15.9 km from City Centre
While staying at the 2-star Point 1 Resort & Motel you are invited to discover Flying Horse Carousel, set a 10-minute ride away, or Napatree Point, which is 10 minutes away by car.
From£ 173 /nightSelect
8.4
Great124 reviews
Map
11.2 km from Fishers Island11.2 km from City Centre
Staying at the 3-star Hyatt Place means you will be approximately 19 minutes' walk from Mystic Seaport Museum, while enjoying a swimming pool onsite.
From£ 89 /nightSelect
8.4
Great233 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
Boasting a heated swimming pool, the 2-star Howard Johnson By Wyndham Mystic is set less than 5 minutes' walk from Olde Mistick Village.
From£ 62 /nightSelect
8.2
Great140 reviews
Map
11.9 km from Fishers Island11.9 km from City Centre
Located near a train station and at a 3.2 km distance from Fields Of Fire Adventure Park, the 3-star Hampton Inn & Suites Mystic offers fitness classes, recreational facilities and entertainment activities.
From£ 86 /nightSelect
8.4
Great173 reviews
Map
13.0 km from Fishers Island13.0 km from City Centre
Located in a business neighbourhood approximately a 7-minute walk from Hygienic Art gallery, the 3-star Holiday Inn New London, An Ihg has 120 rooms and an indoor pool.
From£ 182 /nightSelect
8.2
Great76 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
Set within a 15-minute drive of Stonington Vineyards, the Holiday Inn Express Mystic, An Ihg Mystic lies in a shopping area.
From£ 85 /nightSelect
8.2
Great99 reviews
Map
11.3 km from Fishers Island11.3 km from City Centre
Located in the centre of Groton, the 3-star Hampton Inn Groton/Mystic offers an indoor pool and a lounge bar.
From£ 86 /nightSelect
8.2
Great58 reviews
Map
15.2 km from Fishers Island15.2 km from City Centre
Set 65 km from T.F. Green airport, the Pleasant View Inn Westerly features a swimming pool and a made-to-order breakfast.
From£ 155 /nightSelect
8.0
Great186 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
32 rooms and an outdoor swimming pool are available in the 2-star Rodeway Inn Mystic, located just a 5-minute walk from Olde Mistick Village.
From£ 47 /nightSelect
8.4
Great95 reviews
Map
13.0 km from Fishers Island13.0 km from City Centre
The 3-star Baymont By Wyndham Groton/Mystic Groton lies in a historic district and pampers its guests with a hot tub and an indoor pool.
From£ 86 /nightSelect
8.2
Great37 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
Gold Star Memorial Bridge and Thames River Heritage Park are located 2.6 km and 3.5 km from the 2-star Windsor Groton respectively.
From£ 43 /nightSelect
8.2
Great239 reviews
Map
12.1 km from Fishers Island12.1 km from City Centre
Featuring a swimming pool and 120 rooms, the comfortable Quality Inn Mystic is at a 3.8 km distance from Morgan Point Light.
From£ 61 /nightSelect
8.2
Great206 reviews
Map
15.2 km from Fishers Island15.2 km from City Centre
The welcoming Clarion Inn New London/ Mystic New London features fitness classes, recreational facilities and entertainment activities along with an à la carte restaurant.
From£ 52 /nightSelect
8.4
Great48 reviews
Map
12.2 km from Fishers Island12.2 km from City Centre
Featuring 111 rooms, fitness classes, entertainment activities and barbeque grills, the charming Inn & Suites is about a 20-minute walk from Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park in Groton.
From£ 61 /nightSelect
8.4
Great48 reviews
Map
15.7 km from Fishers Island15.7 km from City Centre
The comfortable 3-star Springhill Suites By Marriott Waterford / Mystic is 25 minutes on foot from Bates Woods Park and offers a swimming pool.
From£ 116 /nightSelect
8.2
Great154 reviews
Map
15.0 km from Fishers Island15.0 km from City Centre
3.1 km from Fort Trumbull State Park and Museum, the cosy Red Roof Inn Mystic features various recreational opportunities and entertainment activities.
From£ 56 /nightSelect
8.2
Great45 reviews
Map
24.0 km from Fishers Island24.0 km from City Centre
Featuring 7 rooms with views of the mountain, the 2-star Stardust Motel is set within 7 km of Artists' Cooperative Gallery of Westerly.
From£ 79 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good104 reviews
Map
9.7 km from Fishers Island9.7 km from City Centre
Bluff Point State Park and Whaling Wall are located 2.3 km and 3.2 km from the 2-star Hilltop Express Inn respectively.
From£ 62 /nightSelect
Inn
8.4
Great152 reviews
Map
8.8 km from Fishers Island8.8 km from City Centre
Set 70 km from T.F. Green airport, the Taber Inn Mystic features an indoor heated swimming pool and a continental breakfast.
From£ 116 /nightSelect
8.4
Great67 reviews
Map
9.3 km from Fishers Island9.3 km from City Centre
Sitting around an 8-minute walk from Mystic Museum of Art, the 3-star Whaler'S Inn is located in a shopping neighbourhood.
From£ 426 /nightSelect
8.0
Great121 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
The facilities of the 3-star Ramada By Wyndham include an indoor pool, fitness classes, spa therapy and entertainment activities.
From£ 40 /nightSelect
8.0
Great107 reviews
Map
12.5 km from Fishers Island12.5 km from City Centre
The Hempsted Houses is also set 10 minutes' drive from the 2-star Super 8 By Wyndham.
From£ 37 /nightSelect
8.4
Great46 reviews
Map
10.8 km from Fishers Island10.8 km from City Centre
Offering a ballroom and a restaurant, the Mystic Marriott Hotel And Spa Groton lies in a business area, nearly a 15-minute ride from The Submarine Force Museum and 20 minutes on foot from Kiely Park.
From£ 117 /nightSelect
8.2
Great129 reviews
Map
11.8 km from Fishers Island11.8 km from City Centre
Boasting access to Mystic River Park nearly a 10-minute drive away, the River Hotel & Suites includes fitness classes, spa therapy and entertainment activities onsite providing guests with spacious rooms.
From£ 91 /nightSelect
8.0
Great12 reviews
Map
8.3 km from Fishers Island8.3 km from City Centre
Offering 6 rooms with views of the river, the prestigious Harbor View Landing is set in a shopping neighbourhood, about a 20-minute stroll from Mystic Seaport Museum.
From£ 232 /nightSelect
8.4
Great45 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
Set a 10-minute ride from Nathan Hale Schoolhouse, the sophisticated 3-star Hilton Garden Inn Mystic/Groton includes 128 rooms, along with a hot tub and an indoor pool.
From£ 90 /nightSelect
7.6
Very good31 reviews
Map
11.9 km from Fishers Island11.9 km from City Centre
The welcoming Rodeway Inn is located in the old part of Groton, within 2.4 km of New London Waterfront Park.
From£ 55 /nightSelect
8.2
Great76 reviews
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
Situated in a business neighbourhood, nearly 25 minutes' walk from Nathan Hale Schoolhouse, the 2-star Motel 6-Groton, Ct - Casinos Nearby Groton accommodates its guests in 95 rooms and offers a Jacuzzi and an indoor pool.
From£ 56 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good50 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
The highest levels of comfort together with entertainment activities and recreational facilities are waiting for you in the 30 rooms for an enjoyable stay at the comfortable Americas Best Value Inn - with a name you can trust.
From£ 48 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good16 reviews
Map
14.0 km from Fishers Island14.0 km from City Centre
Mystic River Park is within 4.8 km of the 3-star House Of 1833 Bed And Breakfast that features a swimming pool.
From£ 240 /nightSelect
Whitehall Mansion
Bed & Breakfast
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
The low-budget Whitehall Mansion is set about a 13-minute walk from Palmer House and an 18-minute walk from Foxwoods Marine Theater.
From£ 119 /nightSelect
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Groton
Hotel
7.8
Very good96 reviews
Map
12.2 km from Fishers Island12.2 km from City Centre
Offering a perfect location near a train station, the 2-star Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Groton features spa therapy and entertainment activities.
From£ 40 /nightSelect
Days Inn & Suites By Wyndham Groton Near The Casinos
Hotel
7.6
Very good64 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
USS Nautilus and Lyman Allyn Art Museum are located 3 km and 3.3 km from the 2-star Days Inn & Suites By Wyndham Groton Near The Casinos respectively.
From£ 47 /nightSelect
Flagship Inn & Suites
Hotel
8.0
Great147 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
Providing travelers with various recreational opportunities and entertainment activities, the lovely 2-star Flagship Inn & Suites Groton is set in a business district, within a 10-minute drive of Gold Star Memorial Bridge.
From£ 35 /nightSelect
Stonecroft Country Inn
Inn
8.2
Great30 reviews
Map
16.7 km from Fishers Island16.7 km from City Centre
Ledyard Congregational Church is also set within 10 minutes' drive of the 4-star Stonecroft Country Ledyard Center.
From£ 155 /nightSelect
Breezeway Resort
Hotel
8.4
Great40 reviews
Map
16.0 km from Fishers Island16.0 km from City Centre
Set in a beach area, the Breezeway Resort features a swimming pool and 50 rooms with beach views.
From£ 232 /nightSelect
Budget Inn North Stonington
Motel
Map
24.4 km from Fishers Island24.4 km from City Centre
Diamond Hill is 5 minutes by car from the Budget Inn North Stonington and Hopkinton City Historic District is about 10 minutes away by car.
From£ 141 /nightSelect
Thames Street Inn
Hotel
7.4
Very good2 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
Old Town Mill is also set 5 minutes by car from the 3-star Thames Street Inn.
Select
Sandy Shore Motel
Motel
8.4
Great1 review
Map
15.9 km from Fishers Island15.9 km from City Centre
While staying at the Sandy Shore Motel you are invited to discover Misquamicut Beach, set a 16-minute walk away, or Water Wizz of Westerly RI, which is a mere 1.3 km away.
Select
The Hotel Maria
Hotel
8.6
Great38 reviews
Map
15.8 km from Fishers Island15.8 km from City Centre
Set within 10 minutes' drive of Napatree Point, the Hotel Maria features a private beach area and a restaurant.
From£ 1 022 /nightSelect
Margin Street Inn
Bed & Breakfast
8.6
Great24 reviews
Map
16.9 km from Fishers Island16.9 km from City Centre
Boasting entertainment activities and water sports facilities, the smoke-free Margin Street Inn is within 5 minutes' stroll of Pawcatuck 7th Day Baptist Church in an entertainment district.
From£ 330 /nightSelect
Sandcastle Beachfront Inn
Inn
Map
15.8 km from Fishers Island15.8 km from City Centre
Located next to Bayview Fun Park, the venue comprises 26 rooms with sea views.
From£ 190 /nightSelect
Super 8 Groton
Hotel
Map
12.6 km from Fishers Island12.6 km from City Centre
The Super 8 is set a 10-minute drive from Nathan Hale Schoolhouse and a 10-minute ride from Hygienic Art gallery.
From£ 107 /nightSelect

Where to stay in Fishers Island?

Best cheap hotels in Fishers Island

Budget hotels can be found in the up-and-coming West Kissimmee district, where you may consider Glenbrook Executive Homes with room rates from 115£ or American Sunshine Hampton Lakes where prices start at 98£. In case you're on a tight budget, stay at Emerald Island 3 Bedroom Townhome Community Pool, which is a 20-minute walk from The Legends Golf Course.

Luxury and boutique accommodation in Fishers Island

We selected top-notch hotels such as American Sunshine Calabay Parc, which price starts from 180£, for those who prefer more space and privacy.

Explore and find your best apartments, B&Bs and others

3 Bedroom Home Kitchen Sleeps 8 is an affordable apartment for families located next to Pandora – The World of Avatar, with room rates from 87£. 3 Bedroom Townhome With West Facing Splash Pool is a quaint choice that is only 10-minute drive to Epcot. If you are here on business, Ocean Florida Villas with rates from 101£ and American Sunshine Disney Area Executive where prices start at 110£ are great options. For a relaxing vacation, book a resort hotel near Mighty Jungle Golf, such as American Sunshine Highlands Reserve or Crystal Cove By Cozykey Vacation Rentals.

Show moreLess

Fishers Island hotels essential information

🏨 Hotels in Fishers Island 48
👛 Lowest price 35 GBP
✍️ Hotels Reviews 4 311