5 star hotels in Long Island

Search among 11 available 5 star hotels in Long Island from 50+ providers

Destination
Where do you want to go?
Check-in
Select date
-
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
1-11 out of 11
Montauk Manor HotelHotel
8.4
Great249 reviews
The smoke-free Manor Montauk with a swimming pool is 10 minutes by car from Hither Woods Preserve.
From£ 123 /nightSelect
The Montauk Soundview HotelHotel
8.2
Great51 reviews
Located a 5-minute walk from Gosman's Dock and within a 10-minute drive of Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course, the 5-star Soundview features a swimming pool and 27 rooms.
From£ 117 /nightSelect
Hyatt Regency Long IslandHotel
8.4
Great97 reviews
The luxury Hyatt Regency Long Island Hauppauge boasts a swimming pool and has 353 rooms, featuring a location close to public transportation.
From£ 86 /nightSelect
Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater SpaResort
8.2
Great58 reviews
Offering mountain biking, hiking and horseback riding in the area, the comfortable Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa lies a 6-minute walk from Hither Hills State Park, and 15 minutes by car from Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course.
From£ 292 /nightSelect
Mill House InnBed & Breakfast
8.4
Great36 reviews
Staying at the 5-star Mill House Inn East Hampton means you will be within a 10-minute drive of Stuart Seafood Market Ltd, while enjoying a swimming pool onsite.
From£ 216 /nightSelect
The Vanderbilt Hotel SuitesHotel
9.6
Perfect1 review
The Vanderbilt Hotel Suites is located 30 km from Republic airport and within 5 minutes' walk of East Gate Boulevard & Zeckendorf Boulevard bus stop.
From£ 229 /nightSelect
The Montauk Beach HouseHotel
8.4
Great40 reviews
Air & Speed is at a 0.9 km distance from the Beach House and Kirk Park Beach is about 6 minutes' walk away.
From£ 415 /nightSelect
The Quogue ClubHotel
8.4
Great13 reviews
Westhampton Beach Farmer's Market is within 3 km of the 5-star Club and Oceanbleu is approximately 3.9 km away.
From£ 432 /nightSelect
Bridgehampton InnHotel
8.4
Great31 reviews
A 10-minute ride from The Madoo Conservancy, the 5-star Inn includes 12 rooms.
From£ 531 /nightSelect
Topping Rose HouseHotel
8.4
Great31 reviews
Featuring American cuisine and an outdoor pool, the 5-star Topping Rose House is located close to a train station and a mere 1.4 km from The Bridgehampton Museum.
From£ 1 837 /nightSelect
The Roundtree, AmagansettHotel
8.4
Great11 reviews
Situated a few steps away from a designer shop and shops, and at a 4.7 km distance from Springs General Store, the 5-star Roundtree, Amagansett offers 15 rooms within a 15-minute drive of Pollock-Krasner House and Study Center.
From£ 899 /nightSelect

5 star hotels in Long Island essential information

🏨 5 star hotels in Long Island 11
👛 Lowest price 86 GBP
✍️ Hotels Reviews 618

FAQs about hotels in Long Island

Discover these 4 answers and find our top hotels in Long Island.

What are the top cheap 5-star hotels in Long Island?

If you want to save up, HotelMix.co.uk offers 16 deals with reasonable prices. For instance, book The Atlantic (rating: 6.6/10), a great deal with a golf course, a seasonal outdoor pool and hiking on site. It costs 151£ per night. Another nice option is Hartman'S Briney Breezes Beach Resort rated 8.4/10 with an outdoor swimming pool, a golf course and concierge service. It costs 239£ per night. Other suitable options include Southampton Long Island Hotel, Born Free Suites By The Sea and Swiss Motel.

What are the top 5-star luxury hotels in Long Island?

For instance, book The Garden City Hotel rated 6.4/10, where prices start from 122£ per night. It's located 10 minutes' walk from Cathedral of the Incarnation and provides steam baths, concierge service and fitness classes on site. Also, you may book Haven Montauk rated 7.6/10 for 410£ per night. It provides windsurfing, diving and hiking, as well as babysitting, housekeeping and bicycle usage on site. Other 5-star luxury hotels include Mill House Inn, Inn At Great Neck,BW Premier Collection and Marram.

What are the top 5-star hotels in Long Island featuring a pool?

Another perfect deal is Courtyard Westbury Long Island rated 7.6/10 with an indoor swimming pool, concierge service and wedding services. This 3-star property will cost you 163£ per night. Other 5-star pool accommodations include The Ocean Resort Inn, Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven and Windward Shores.

Which 5-star hotels in Long Island near a beach are the best?

If you want your stay to be pleasant, there are 3 options to consider. For instance, book Hotel Indigo East End,An Ihg Hotel (rating: 7.0/10), a perfect hotel near a beach with a casino, a golf course and free shuttle bus service on site. It costs 192£ per night. Alternative, book Tides Inn At Stehli Beach rated 8.2/10 for 62£ per night. It's set 5 minutes' walk from the beach and features a swimming pool, cars and ironing.